Catrin Stewart and Neve McIntosh are back as Jenny and Vastra. |
For any die-hard fan of Doctor Who, this was a bit of a love
letter, wasn’t it? We see every incarnation of the Doctor thus far in this
episode – albeit a couple of them are incredibly fleeting (Paul McGann
especially). We have Clara popped into the various Doctor’s timelines with some
pretty nice (although some think a little crude) special effects work. We have
the Vastra/Jenny/Strax team back together (yet still no clue as to who brought
Strax back to life) again, and they are always great and Dan Starkey is just
brilliantly funny, Richard E. Grant as the Great Intelligence, Trenzalore, and
thankfully the ‘name’ of the Doctor is not revealed, but in fact it’s about
what he stands for, what he does. Because frankly if we ever learn his name
there’s nothing I can think of that would make it that special – ie – ‘Ok,
you’ve got me, my name is Bert!’ Not going to live up to expectations.
Richard E Grant is also back! |
Was there much of a plot? Nah. It wasn’t that sort of
episode. It was basically answering the question we’ve wondered since ‘Asylum
of the Daleks’, ‘Who is Clara Oswald?’. And we get a bit of glee with Clara
interacting with William Hartnell. Interestingly, the sets were pretty limited
in this story. I imagine the working of Clara into old footage, and the
colourisation of Hartnell must have cost a bit, so we don’t get a lot of
different sets – although they weren’t needed. There isn’t a lot of location
shooting either – I suspect that the house Clara lives in is a location, but
aside from that it seems mostly in-studio. I guess it helps keep secrets.
So are we satisfied with Clara’s story? Look, the resolution
was very good, I liked it a lot. The only issue I had with it was Clara’s willingness
to jump into the time stream, admittedly aided by the fact that she had been
told she was the impossible girl the Doctor had met twice before, but had she
formed as strong a bond between herself and the Doctor to go ahead and jump? I
wasn’t quite convinced, I felt there needed a bit more in the scripts, or
indeed more time for that bond to be so strong like Rose or Amy.
Nevertheless, great stuff. Less unanswered questions than
usual too for a series finale, which is nice. Would really love a two-part
series finale though! And then the teaser for the 50th anniversary
special – the reveal of John Hurt as the Doctor! The captioning, they could
have done without. Really it added nothing to the episode and generally Doctor
Who has not done that sort of self-referential mularky in the past.
All in all, a fantastic way to end the series, lots of
‘squee’ moments for the fans, wraps up Clara’s storyline, I really enjoyed
this. Series 7B has ended on a high with the last few episodes, after the first
4-5 episodes, solid as they were, for me failed to reach any great heights.
Maybe Mr Moffatt was a bit unsure where he was taking the Series? The thing is,
unlike the RTD era where we had oncoming menace that the Doctor would have to
face at the end of the 13-episode run, Moffatt has chosen to arc series with a
central question (with the exception of series five, which I think was the best
Steven Moffatt series). In series 6 it was ‘does the Doctor die? And if not,
how does he avoid death?’, Series seven it was ‘Who is Clara?’. I felt like
RTD’s stuff built better because you got more pieces to the puzzle as it moved
along – Series Three, despite its dreadful end, did this best of all.
As for the situation at the moment with split series and the
like, Moffatt may feel that that won’t work so well. It’s easier to remember
one single question during the mid-series break, than a whole set of elements
that are building towards something more significant. Anyhoo, as an episode
this one was great!
8.5/10
No comments:
Post a Comment